Cover Versions Better Than The Originals

Shadow Leader

At the Start
Joined
Nov 9, 2003
Messages
9,884
I know that generally cover versions are crap, but I was listening to the radio on the way to the airport this morning when Elton John's Your Song came on - personally, I think that Ewan Macgregor's version in Moulin Rouge was far, far better than Elton's original. Can't think of many others that were better than the original; Counting Crow's Big Yellow Taxi was a good cover but not better htan the original, although Stereophonic's version of Handbags & Gladrags was better than Rod Stewart's, I thought.
 
Thought I'd mention the obvious one - Hendrix's version of Dylan's All Along The Watchtower was brilliant. Though the original was still seriously good, I think Hendrix's imitation of the harmonica with the guitar was beautiful.
 
I agree. Also,

Radiohead - Nobody Does it Better
Flaming Lips - Somewhere over the Rainbow
Niel Hannon - Life on Mars (close call that as the original was ace)
Manic Street Preachers - Theme from M*A*S*H
Travis - Baby one more Time
 
You are a dead man....
gun4.gif
 
:blink: :lol: Yikes . I hope Lord H is'nt as fond of Elvis as he is Sinatra or I may get concrete boots too . I nominate Nick Cave's version of In the Ghetto .
 
Clash - I Fought the Law
Beatles - Twist and Shout
Oasis - Cum on feel the noiz
Sid Vicious - My Way
Rolling Stones - It's All Over Now
Pogues - Dirty Old Town
Thin Lizzy - Whisky in the Jar
 
Tom Jones and Cerys Matthews version of Baby its Cold Outside ( if thats its title..... ) MUCH better than Dolly Parton or the other persons.....

Agree with Stereophonics Handbags and Gladrags too...
 
I prefer the Rod Stewart version. I saw him perform it at Glastonbury and my preference may well have something to with the 6 violinists he had on stage with him in very small skirts.



Yes, I am shallow!!
 
I think all you youngsters should be aware that the original version of Handbags and Gladrags wasn't by Rod Stewart. It was written by Mike D'Abo (replacement singer in Manfred Mann for Paul Jones) and, as far as I'm aware, the first hit version was by Chris Farlowe.
 
And the original version of "Baby, It's Cold Outside" was sung in the film "Neptune's Daughter" by Esther Williams and (I think) Ricardo Montalban.
 
Mike D’Abo was educated in Harrow, a suburban area of North-London. It was while at school that Mike formed a pop group called A Band of Angels. Initially an amateur outfit playing pop covers at dances and parties, they were good enough to secure a record contract in 1964 and turned professional.
The Angels made and released a number of recordings, although they did not achieve notable chart success (I must confess, I have no recollection of the group at all). Two of their tracks, Hide ‘n Seek and (Accept my) Invitation were strong enough to get included in various sixties compilation albums. Mike D’Abo himself played piano and guitar and, of course, provided the lead vocals. His instrumental skill was such that he was allowed to play on the studio recordings of their songs, whereas the other band members were replaced by session men.
With or without chart hits, Mike D’Abo established enough of a reputation so that in mid 1966 he was chosen to replace Paul Jones as lead singer of top group Manfred Mann. The Manfreds had a number of big hits (including 54321 and Do Wah Diddy) behind them and it was a massive coup to be chosen to front them. In fact, Mike did not disappoint and with his vocals the Manfreds went on to their greatest period of success.
 
BABY IT'S COLD OUTSIDE
(Frank Loesser)

Johnny Mercer & Margaret Whiting - 1949
Buddy Clark & Dinah Shore - 1949
Louis Jordan & Ella Fitzgerald - 1949
Don Cornell & Laura Leslie - 1949
Homer & Jethro with June Carter - 1949
Dean Martin & Chorus - 1959
Ray Charles & Betty Carter - 1961
Al Hirt & Ann-Margret - 1964
Tom Jones & Cerys Matthews - 1999

Also recorded by : Albert & Gage; Louis Armstrong;
Christina Saffran Ashford; Asylum Street Spankers; The Avalanches;
Pearl Baily; Blowfly; Jessica Simpson, and many others ...
 
UB40 - Red red wine
Marmalade - Obla di Obla da
Puff Daddy - I'll be missing you/Every breath you take

Being an old Slade fan I can't possibly agree about Come on feel the noise.
 
Still think TJ and CM version is the best - probably cos I love big band music....

Also much prefer Michael Buble's covers of any songs to most of the origionals, though you are hard pushed to better Sinatra origionals.....

and.....

never heard the origional, but I love Robson and Jerome ( :shy: I know!!! )'s and also Will Young's version of A Nightingale Sang In Berkeley Square. ( have a soft spot for swing too.... )
 
Forgot about the M*A*S*H theme tune - fantastic stuff. Another one is a song my brother dug out the other dayby a fella called Israel Kamakawiwo`ole, a cover of Somewhere Over The Rainbow merged with What a Wonderful World, it is a superb version. After hearing it, I commented to my brother that I had heard it on something that may me cry a lot, but we could only find it on the soundtracks of Finding Forrester & Meet Joe Black before coincidentally hearing it played on another film's soundtrack the day after. I have just found where I know it from on the net, it was used in Dr Greene's last episode in ER, one which I cried throughout the entirety.
 
ONLY THAT ONE SONG !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :o :o :o


Promise!!!!! ( and its such a lovely song i dont think it would matter who sings it... like Teenage Kicks )


Also like John Otways Two Little Boys......
 
Back
Top