There is no superstar out there at the minute and I refuse to believe Sir Des Champs is all that.
The penny has probably dropped with the raters now. At their best Kauto and Denman were 180+ winners of the Gold Cup. Unfortunately neither were at that level since 2008/9 (at Cheltenham) hence Imperial Commander and Long Run being incredibly overrated.
Hard to argue with you there as a general point but iirc didn't Long Run beat track record ( haven't checked)
I think you're correct about BM beating an Imperial Commander or a Long Run. But a top form Denman would have dismantled him.
Does anyone seriously think Hunt Ball is a Gold Cup winner next year.