I don't think so - I've read Ruthless Reviews from time to time, and Matt Cale, while clearly in love with Matt Cale the ruthless reviewer, does hit a helluva lot of nails bang on the head. The review of 'Top Gun', for example, is relevant - horribly so - to America's 'Top Cock' military bullying today. The ghastly, schmaltzy 'po' boy done good' movies which dot the American filmscape do also point to a very American sentimentalisation of the innate good of the poor. Which is pure social crap - the poor in America will forever remain poor unless they set up drug cartels and rob banks. American jails are full of American poor, and for decade after decade, poor black Americans have been and are far more likely to be fatally gassed, jabbed or fritzed than their criminal white counterparts. Jimmy Stewart's fine thespian skills have singularly failed to sway any of those good ole boys heading up the Deep South's courtrooms.
The films Cale's selected haven't ruined anything except a couple of hours misspent watching them: some were a joke to start with (I mean, come on, did anybody really weep over 'Love Story' or find it the slightest bit better than a slushy Mills & Boon romance novel?), Forrest Gump was peurile tosh (yes, life's just like a box of chocolates - sometimes you get to eat the whole lot, and sometimes you get a nut allergy from the pralines). Most of the films are old and outdated and represented no known reality, just overblown emoting or unrealistic moralising. But I bet there's a further ten that any of us could add... :brows: