Diamond Geezer
Gone But Not Forgotten
- Joined
- May 2, 2003
- Messages
- 13,884
I took 12/1 Pic D’Orhy last week or so when Nicholls talked about its rating based on its French form and I see it seems stronger than Quel Destin in the teatime market but Cobden is sticking with the latter.
I've had a wee pop at Pic D'Orhy (14/1) ahead of its race tomorrow.
On the eve of the Triumph Hurdle I wrote:
Looking back, I now wonder if Newbury has been the plan all along. Anyway, I wouldn't have written the above if there wasn't something significant in what Nicholls had said. I don't remember exactly what he did say but it must have been along the lines of this one being the best of his juveniles. He isn't entered in the Champion Hurdle, which I'm note sure how to interpret but I suspect if he turns up at Newbury with Cobden aboard he'll be a single figure price and if he wins tomorrow he shorten up anyway. It's only sickness insurance really, though.
Yes, that's a fair summary of Nicholls's comments last Feb.
Pic D'Orhy is introduced on the 16-minute mark:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NtzQf6yQX1Q
He was a top class juvenile in France and did very well over the summer, so it was unfortunate that he fell at Auteuil first time out this season. Pic d'Orhy is a lovely horse who is going to make a top chaser so we have been patient with him and are half waiting for next season when he goes over fences.
We still don't know if his rating of 146 is a fair one but we do like him, there is improvement to come and this race will tell us plenty. If he runs well at Ascot then the obvious target is the Betfair Hurdle at Newbury.
I haven't backed it today as I feared a pipe-opener was on the cards.
Whether his original 149 rating was a guess is another matter. The handicapper will have checked him out a lot more thoroughly than the average UK punter. I wonder if any enthusiast out there keeps track of how handicap marks based on French form tend to work out.
In any event, Nicholls felt he had some good juveniles last season and appeared to rate this one right up there with the best of them.
You also know how I think, Slim. I tend to believe most decent juveniles will improve 10lb into the next season (and a further 10lb once they go chasing). So I'm thinking maybe Nicholls regards PDO as a 159/160 5yo and a 170 chaser in the making. He also ran PDO in a G1 in France. I reckon that shouldn't be dismissed. And he won the Betfair with 5yo Zarkandar off 151.
I wouldn't be averse to backing the horse again if he runs badly today, especially if he goes out in the betting.
Today's Betfair blog comment:
I don't think Oakley can finish in front of him even with a 7lb swing. He looks very high off 139. Getting beat by a 3yo hurdler is not great form.
The above will be thoroughly exposed for the unadulterated twaddle that is in a few weeks.
You just don't know what a price you'll be missing out on. You really don't.
"He looks very high off 139".
I think thats code for...'I don't respect this horse or what Marb explained about him...and he wouldn't win an egg and spoon race off 125'
Eldorado Allen is entered in a listed race against Call Me Lord on Saturday.It's a big deal if he runs there and skips running off 152 in the Betfair.
Or they fancy their chances against odds on Call Me Lord. If he’s a genuine Champ Hurdle horse he should be going close.
I’d rather take my chances against Call Me Lord than take on a big field handicap.
Wouldn't that imply that they don't think he can win the much bigger prize off 152?