-
REGISTER NOW!! Why? Because you can't do much without having been registered!
At the moment you have limited access to view all discussions - and most importantly, you haven't joined our community. What are you waiting for? Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join Join Talking Horses here!
Hong Kong Racing - Horse Race Analysis, Tips, Predictions & Live Races For Sha Tin & Happy Valley
- Thread starter chaumi
- Start date
chaumi
Rookie
fwiw here's what my AI said...
Sha Tin is a very distinctive racecourse, so there’s no perfect European equivalent — but several tracks share key characteristics such as long straights, fair galloping layouts, and an emphasis on stamina and strong finishers.
Here’s the clearest comparison:
Those traits help us map it to European tracks:
Why it matches Sha Tin:
Differences:
Why it matches:
Differences:
Why it matches:
Differences:
Why it matches:
Differences:
Sha Tin is a very distinctive racecourse, so there’s no perfect European equivalent — but several tracks share key characteristics such as long straights, fair galloping layouts, and an emphasis on stamina and strong finishers.
Here’s the clearest comparison:
- Right-handed
- Big, galloping track with long sweeping turns
- Very long home straight (≈ 430m turf)
- Fair track: strong horses, good travellers, and late kickers excel
- Fast ground common
- Races favour strong tempo control and clean acceleration
Those traits help us map it to European tracks:
Curragh (Ireland) — Most similar overall
Why it matches Sha Tin:
- Wide, galloping, “power track” that rewards sustained speed
- Long straights and fair stretch run
- Top-class turf racing, often on sound or quick ground
- Horses need stamina + acceleration, just like Sha Tin’s pattern
Differences:
- Curragh is left-handed with undulations; Sha Tin is right-handed and flatter.
Newbury (UK) — Very close in racing style
Why it matches:
- Big, open, galloping track
- Horses with a long stride excel
- Long straight encourages strong finishing runs
- Similar profile: “fair”, tempo-driven, and rewards rhythm runners
Differences:
- Newbury is left-handed and turf-only
- Sha Tin has both turf & all-weather
Ascot (UK) — Finishing style most similar
Why it matches:
- Long, stamina-testing straight
- Requires strong, balanced horses who can quicken off a honest pace
- High-quality turf surface where class matters
- Long races feel tactically similar to Sha Tin’s layout
Differences:
- Ascot’s uphill finish makes it more demanding than Sha Tin
- Sha Tin tends to play more to speed than grind
Deauville (France) — Most similar for the all-weather track
Why it matches:
- High-quality Polytrack similar to Sha Tin’s all-weather surface
- Suits strong travellers and horses with tactical speed
- Wide, fair track with a long straight
Differences:
- Deauville turf course is more European-soft; Sha Tin turf is usually firm.
The Fortune Teller
Journeyman
- Joined
- Mar 8, 2016
- Messages
- 8,782
What type of good ground are we looking at guys?
It seems there's a concern Sosie might need it softer, but I think he might just handle it, (Sandown good to firm run needs a line putting through), and he's got the form to win this.
It seems there's a concern Sosie might need it softer, but I think he might just handle it, (Sandown good to firm run needs a line putting through), and he's got the form to win this.
Euronymous
Senior Jockey
I think Sosie is a turd
The Fortune Teller
Journeyman
- Joined
- Mar 8, 2016
- Messages
- 8,782
I always respect what you think fella but nah.
I reckon he's enough in hand the carry these. It's plausible backers could get 4/1 or 9/2 by off time.
Aslong as there's no firm in the description I think he'll handle it.
He was in front of Giavellotto in the Arc, who won this race last year, and he can confirm the placings here.
I reckon he's enough in hand the carry these. It's plausible backers could get 4/1 or 9/2 by off time.
Aslong as there's no firm in the description I think he'll handle it.
He was in front of Giavellotto in the Arc, who won this race last year, and he can confirm the placings here.
Last edited:
Euronymous
Senior Jockey
I think he's bang average and 10f soft is his bag. He's surely too short.
The Fortune Teller
Journeyman
- Joined
- Mar 8, 2016
- Messages
- 8,782
Fair enough. I'd happily see him drift, because I know for the most part why that'll be.
Let's see what happens.
Did you ask where it derived it's info from? cos unless you feed chatgpt, claude etc your own quality data they're basically a very fancy internet search , aggregator & summariserfwiw here's what my AI said...
Sha Tin is a very distinctive racecourse, so there’s no perfect European equivalent — but several tracks share key characteristics such as long straights, fair galloping layouts, and an emphasis on stamina and strong finishers.
Here’s the clearest comparison:
- Right-handed
- Big, galloping track with long sweeping turns
- Very long home straight (≈ 430m turf)
- Fair track: strong horses, good travellers, and late kickers excel
- Fast ground common
- Races favour strong tempo control and clean acceleration
Those traits help us map it to European tracks:
Why it matches Sha Tin:
- Wide, galloping, “power track” that rewards sustained speed
- Long straights and fair stretch run
- Top-class turf racing, often on sound or quick ground
- Horses need stamina + acceleration, just like Sha Tin’s pattern
Differences:
- Curragh is left-handed with undulations; Sha Tin is right-handed and flatter.
Why it matches:
- Big, open, galloping track
- Horses with a long stride excel
- Long straight encourages strong finishing runs
- Similar profile: “fair”, tempo-driven, and rewards rhythm runners
Differences:
- Newbury is left-handed and turf-only
- Sha Tin has both turf & all-weather
Why it matches:
- Long, stamina-testing straight
- Requires strong, balanced horses who can quicken off a honest pace
- High-quality turf surface where class matters
- Long races feel tactically similar to Sha Tin’s layout
Differences:
- Ascot’s uphill finish makes it more demanding than Sha Tin
- Sha Tin tends to play more to speed than grind
Why it matches:
- High-quality Polytrack similar to Sha Tin’s all-weather surface
- Suits strong travellers and horses with tactical speed
- Wide, fair track with a long straight
Differences:
- Deauville turf course is more European-soft; Sha Tin turf is usually firm.
I once went down the route of trying to determine 'similar' courses via data mining and stats by looking at say Ascot and 5-6f races and the cross referencing the runners over a 20 year period against other courses and 5-6f races to see which courses they've done well at both.
You need to use big datasets to tune out some of noise and get a suitable high level view.
Took a lot of computing horse power to run but some of the results seemed quite interesting I seem to remember.
Tom Foolery
Amateur Rider
I think Giavellotto finishes ahead of Sosie on this ground, was nothing between them in the Arc and that was on ground that Sosie loves and Giavellotto hates .
Al Riffa could be the main danger though , for all his best form comes over further he's ran some cracking races at this distance and with being drawn 2 will probably just bounce out and make it a big test of stamina for the rest of them .
Last edited:
