-
REGISTER NOW!! Why? Because you can't do much without having been registered!
At the moment you have limited access to view all discussions - and most importantly, you haven't joined our community. What are you waiting for? Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join Join Talking Horses here!
Hawk Wing is dead
- Thread starter Ardross
- Start date
granger
Senior Jockey
A rare flat horse I liked
The Fortune Teller
Journeyman
- Joined
- Mar 8, 2016
- Messages
- 8,759
One of the best horses not to win a 2000 Guineas?
Slim
Rookie
- Joined
- Dec 6, 2019
- Messages
- 4,155
Top 3 for sure.
walsworth
Journeyman
One of my favourites
Overrated due to a soft lead,and never matched that performance,before or since.
Ian_Davies
Conditional
granger
Senior Jockey
Hopefully the latter
Well he was injured in the Queen Anne .
edgt
Senior Jockey
He holds the all aged record for 7 furlongs at The Curragh for his National Stakes win as a juvenile. Draw at the wrong side at Newmarket and soft ground plus High Chapparal scuppered his Derby bid though the third was 12 lengths back .
An unlucky horse to be the same age as Rock Of Gibraltar and High Chapparal I bet he frustrated the s778te out of all at Ballydoyle .
An unlucky horse to be the same age as Rock Of Gibraltar and High Chapparal I bet he frustrated the s778te out of all at Ballydoyle .
Ian_Davies
Conditional
Talented horse, but I was never really a fan.
Lots of horses are "unlucky" to be born in the same year as other horses (how many times did Excelebration see Frankel's backside at the business end, for example?).
Arguably wasn't given a great ride in the 2,000 Guineas, but a truly great horse would have defied that IMO, beaten fair and square in The Derby where IMO he didn't really stay (yes, the third was 12 lengths away but the also rans weren't up to much and for me he just didn't see it out) and had things his own way in that Lockinge.
But it's a game of opinions, we all have our differing criteria for greatness and none of us is categorically right and none of us is categorically wrong (though there's always plenty of ****s in this game ready to tell us we are).
Lots of horses are "unlucky" to be born in the same year as other horses (how many times did Excelebration see Frankel's backside at the business end, for example?).
Arguably wasn't given a great ride in the 2,000 Guineas, but a truly great horse would have defied that IMO, beaten fair and square in The Derby where IMO he didn't really stay (yes, the third was 12 lengths away but the also rans weren't up to much and for me he just didn't see it out) and had things his own way in that Lockinge.
But it's a game of opinions, we all have our differing criteria for greatness and none of us is categorically right and none of us is categorically wrong (though there's always plenty of ****s in this game ready to tell us we are).
edgt
Senior Jockey
Fair to say he showed a rare depth of talent once every season, a Gallic Warrior of the flat .
The Lockinge could nearly have been called off with high wind and rain , Hawk Wing ran so fast he dried himself as he ran . Maybe he just too much out of himself when right that he could not repeat the dose regularly.
The Lockinge could nearly have been called off with high wind and rain , Hawk Wing ran so fast he dried himself as he ran . Maybe he just too much out of himself when right that he could not repeat the dose regularly.
