I will ask you a question. Why do you think analysing races, either by pace, ratings etc is a bad thing and somehow inferior to using your eyes or ears?
If you watch a race and a horse wins by 20 lengths easing down. How do you know how good that performance was by eye?
Ratings I can't abide to be honest MOST of the time.
Over the years I have seen some crackers........Dream Ahead was rated higher than frankel and I asked Paul Struthers of TRF how on earth did they come up with that nonsense.
His reply left me dumfounded when he told it was based on him beateing some horse that had finished behind him 3rd or 4th and gone on to win a group 1 race.
On the day he was 128 Frankel 123 and ofcourse we know what happened.
Then there was Master Minded beating the grossly overrated VPU (At 2 miles) and given a rating Higher than both Kauto and Denman which was complete Nonsense.
The baaeed who I kept saying had beat nothing as Mishrif was a shadow of himself....that bugged me.
Of course they get some right and some wrong but I very seldom get involved.....beause the h'capper is a creature of habit......win a grade 2 up you go even if you beat a monkey.
Your other question I can honestly say I don't know. I know when Constitution Hill won the Supreme I had witnessed something very very special.
Anyone that was on TRF when Binocular won his first race at Kempton I said he would win a Champion Hurdle and when Sprinter Sacre jumped the 5th fence at Doncaster I said he was the knew Arkle.
How I knew they were oustanding performances I am damned if I know but when I see one I think is exceptional. like when I saw Galopin Des Champs win at Leopardstown last year I said he was a Gold Cup horse...despite it being over much shorter.
I am sure many others who just watch racing have had similar experiences..It doesn't make you special it's just a buzz you get that grabs your attention,
For me pace doesn't come into it good horse win off slow fast moderate or whatever pace. On everday average racing I don't have the patience or the desire to start analyzing pace.
Jockeys however ar only human and they very often get it wrong as do we all when it comes to racing.....I backed a forecast to day at 10/11 Constutution Hill and Epatante then lost what I won on Envoi Allen to be placed....sadly for me being placed last don't count:lol: