Colin Phillips
At the Start
Can this thread be decribed as an argument or just contradiction?
I've been thinking something similar since yesterday's big hcap chase at Kempton.
I know that's a bit like going from the ridiculous to the sublime and that the two races couldn't be much different but the principle is there.
Horses that have appeared to struggle for pace were suddenly out there cutting away at their fences and not stopping. It was a great race to watch and I backed four in it. Not one of the four got a look in at any time.
Compare that with the Eider on soft/heavy. I narrowed it down to four. At best morning odds they dutched at somewhere between evens and 10/11 so I went for the pound signs and put all my eggs in the Springfield Fox basket each-way only to see it try to make all and fade, the other thee filling the first three places.
I suspect what we see in the Champion Hurdle might not be what we anticipate.
While I've enjoyed most of the thread I haven't tried to over-think it too much. So far, all I've really done is look at my figures and see how they compare with what it takes to win a modest, average, good or top renewal.
I'm still not sure what this year's will be.
Honeysuckle and Epatante are mares. In a proper era they'd be handicapping if it weren't for the allowance.
One run suddenly makes Silver Streak and Goshen contenders.
Think back to when Espoir D'Allen ran away from Melon in a huge time. Suddenly he was the next superstar. Within a year everyone was saying what a crap renewal it had been.
Like I say, I've just looked at figures and compared them with past standards with a view to snaffling some ante-post value. I haven't even thought about how the race might be won.
I might do so at the five-day stage but right now the one I'm most drawn to (and is already my biggest potential winner ante-post) is Buveur D'Air. His best form is more than 7lbs better than either of the mares'.
Having read and considered all the inputs I'm coming down on the side of a Epatante/Buveur forecast. The overrated Goshen and the stayer, Honetsuckle will do each other in by the turn,
Can this thread be decribed as an argument or just contradiction?
Trusting the forecast, I reckon it will be g/s ground on the qpening day, and the executive will strive to ensure it's no quicker. For mine that would make it a speed test, and (unsurprisingly) I feel Goshen is best equipped to deal with it. Don't forget he had the Triumph (albeit on the stiffer track) shot to bits when he came down last year, and on ground the RP timed as the same g/s. Might be worth considering he was racing against novices then, but RPR's show him as having made normal improvement from novice to 5yo, so no great worries there.2013 was salvation. The Fly and Solwhit. A glorious, glorious year.
But we digress.
I reckon we should be factoring the going more into our calculations. Most of the field have produced their best form on genuinely soft-ground, and I reckon it’s going to be pretty quick, no matter how much Claisse pours on to keep ‘Soft’ somewhere in the description. Fast pace and relatively-fast ground could see a bit of a mad result.
Did you fancy Honeysuckle for the Champion before her last run, or was it her last 'performance' that made you think actually she is a proper Champion horse?
I'd suggest you wouldn't know much about The Great Man's MO.
In other words, he can't beat Epatante?
Isn't that what I said?They must be hugely confident about her that they don't need Buvi as a second string to their bow......
Boov swerving Cheltenham says a lot more about Boov than it does Epatante, imo.
Does this mean Nico will ride Epatante? Unless there is another Hendo runner from The yard I'm missing?
He can't beat anything, he is gone at the game.In other words, he can't beat Epatante?
He can't beat anything, he is gone at the game.
No, He will be on Buzz
Navajo pass gave the form a great boost the other day also.....Ballyandy too.
Returning from injury after 12 months off, then beaten 4l on the dreadful ground. He's won at Liverpool before, and at Punchestown...
Liverpool comes 3 weeks later, he'll go there fresh and I'm sure you'll change your mind about his condition!
Navajo pass gave the form a great boost the other day also.....
I was taking the p1ss.The Navajo Pass that ran to an RPR of 129 in his last run, or the Navajo Pass that ran to 157 and 154 on his previous two runs...
Because if he ran to anywhere near that mark last time out, then Goshen ran to a near 200