This was an article I was looking on the RP site for ages...Willoughby's views on the Epsom Derby:
James Willoughby 08 JUNE 2009
IN THESE pages nine years ago, the sectionals of John Oxx's other Derby winner made for a fascinating study. I described Sinndar's defeat of Sakhee as a race in which two special horses had survived a severely punishing gallop to record top-class performances on the clock.
Sea The Stars is almost certainly a racehorse of the same order, but his own Derby win could not have been more different in terms of pace.
As a result, we learned more about Galileo's half-brother from our senses than is evident from the bare facts of his performance.
In terms of time and form, Sea The Stars did not post the kind of effort on Saturday that we think is within his range.
The inference that he is an exceptional athlete can be made from a combination of his winning both the Stanjames.com 2,000 Guineas and the Investec Derby, and that he does nearly everything right in his races.
At the same time, as we giddily admire him as an individual, marvel at his accomplishments and wonder how high he might fly, a mood of greater sobriety is forced upon us when looking at the sectional times of his victory.
Sea The Stars probably used excessenergy in the opening furlongs of the Derby, and he probably had more left at the end, but he simply did not face the kind of adversity that he should have.
Coarsely expressed, the Derby turned into a downhill sprint in which a 2,000 Guineas winner was given a running start over the stayer Fame And Glory, and did not defeat him any further than when he started the dash.
In that article in 2000, I recorded the sectional times for Sinndar himself at three points around the course demarked by paths. These neatly sub-divide the Derby course into bite-sized chunks which make the race easily understandable from a pace standpoint.
Fortunately, Sea The Stars recorded a final time within 0.01sec of the other Oxx hero, giving the sectionals a tremendous descriptive quality in comparison. And the tale they have to tell is remarkable.
In the table, I have headed the columns as if the sectionals were taken to furlong poles. It does not matter they were not, so long as the same points were used; it is their relativity that is interesting, but I shall refer to them by their approximate measure for ease.
And this is the shocking truth: Sinndar covered the first five furlongs of theDerby more than five seconds faster than Sea The Stars. That is the difference between night and day in pace terms, an amazing disparity which perfectly highlights just how slowly the 2009 Derby was relative to the 2000 edition.
In the latter, Sinndar earned an outstanding Topspeed figure of 126, which implies he went at a solid pace all the way. But that was not the case this year; they went steadily to the highest point of the course, then came flying down the straight.
Sea The Stars probably did a little too much in the opening furlongs, even though the pace, set by the Aidan O'Brien-trained Golden Sword, was tepid. That he did not ruin his chance completely is a further indication that both horse and riderMick Kinane are splendidly professional individuals.
After about five furlongs - a furlong before the highest point of the course - the sectionals show that the pace of the 2009 Derby was much greater than in 2000.
This is partly because the leaders were winded in the 2000 renewal, though a comparison with other years does suggest O'Donoghue and Smullen kicked on a bit.
But where was Fame And Glory? At this point in the 2002 Derby won by HighChaparral, Johnny Murtagh had pushed up the winner from a position two lengths behind the brilliant miler Hawk Wing to stalk the pace, and from there he had launched the strong stayer in an all-out assault for the line.
This tactic was successful in drawing the sting out of Hawk Wing, but no such challenge was issued to this year's hero.
I am happy to admit that if Hawk Wing had enjoyed the same trip in his year as Sea The Stars, he would probably have bolted up.
It takes a jockey of individualism, bravado and experience to execute a tactic like that, but Murtagh was sadly on the back of Rip Van Winkle, instead of where he should have been.
It is unfair to Seamie Heffernan to say he should have launched Fame And Glory for the lead, but he surely should have been in front of Sea The Stars at some point. L ET'S put it this way: if Sea The Stars dares to line up in the Dubai Duty Free Irish Derby, he's likely to face a very different scenario.
Presumably, he would have it put up to him from an early stage. And if that is the consensus, then we can equally agree that it should have happened on Saturday.
In the event, Sea The Stars was more than a match for Golden Sword and Age Of Aquarius, but we already knew that. It is frustrating that the 2009 Derby was not an epic encounter between Sea The Stars and Fame And Glory because it simply was not a stern test of stamina.
In the estimation of the master trainer Oxx, Sea The Stars and Sinndar may be horses of quite polar athletic attributes, but both encountered the type of Derby that suited them. Right now, it seems that Sea The Stars could beat any horse in any circumstances, but those horses who are actually at this elevated level are much rarer than those who are simply perceived to be.
Watching the superb Sea The Stars in his pomp was a terrific sight, but we did not see him tested by having to run past Fame And Glory in a rare Derby when being further forward was an advantage.
Hopefully, that scenario may well be to come.
And now his views on the Irish Derby:
By James Willoughby 29 JUNE 2009
IT WAS perfect because it was just so simple. It was a moment of complete triumph for Aidan O'Brien and for Ballydoyle. And it showed.
The Dubai Duty Free Irish
Derby was a great celebration of the horse - before, during and after. There were great scenes when Fame And Glory paraded in front of the stands in triumph, Johnny Murtagh punching the air.
All it took was a proper gallop. There was no contortion of Fame And Glory'sathletic ability because the imposter Rip Van Winkle did not have to be catered for this time.
Instead, they let the true champion do his thing - with the stable jockey where he should have been at Epsom. As expected, Fame And Glory andMurtagh absolutely crushed them..
What a shame Sea The Stars was not around. He might have sprinted past Golden Sword at Epsom with more ease than Fame And Glory did here, but that was after a joke pace by Derby standards.
All the plaudits that went to Sea The Stars last time were deserved. His fleet of foot, the imperious way he comports himself, his utter superiority on the day.
But this time you had to give it to Fame And Glory. His brand of dominance is not of such high mettle, not of the finer kind, but honest, brutal, straightforward, unwavering.
He is everything we thought he was: a top-class staying machine who can survive any fractions, a relentless converter of every cell of energy into sustained pace to fire his slow-twitch muscles that will just fire all day. IT IS so sad that there is an obsession with speed in the thoroughbred.
Fame And Glory has plenty of it, just like Yeats, but their ability to pound out 12-second furlongs is gilded by precious stamina.
And that is fantastic to see in the four-time Gold Cup winner and the Irish Derby hero alike.
The real point about stamina is rarely made. It is not just about producing loveable old stayers who recall the old days; it is not just about preserving tradition and showing resolution against flimsy modernity, nor is it bowing to cheap, commercial trends..
There is no such physiological quantity as stamina. It is not transmitted as a gene, nor does it exist in the blood.
It is a collection of physical and mental attributes in the thoroughbred that enable it to carry its speed.
But this capacity is often closely related to the expression of what we perceive as courage and generosity: the ability to withstand pressure, to go through the pain barrier, to be resolute against the physical forces opposing forward motion.
Fame And Glory is the poster boy for this elite. Now, any horse who runs against him knows what they are going to get. If he meets Sea The Stars again, the champion won't get by on class for a second time.
"It was a very easy win," said Murtagh. "I knew from the way he had worked during the week that he was going to do something like this." Then, smiling at the perfect question from Gary O'Brien on At The Races, he added: "Sea The Stars is one-nil up, but it is a long year and I'm sure we'll meet again." From this, one senses Fame And Glory is a monster just waking up from youthful slumbers. That he has done a lot so far on natural talent, without his mind being sharpened in combat as much as it should.
And that is where his trainer excels. And where he will take over.
This was a great day for Irish racing. But there will be a better one when Fame And Glory gets another crack at Sea The Stars.
Make it a mile and a half, make it a mile and a quarter. It does not matter. Just make it a strong gallop.