I'm still firmly in the Epatante camp. She's allowed an off day. Her off day is far less concerning than the inconsistencies we've seen from the pretenders.
Last seasons novices are unexposed and entitled to improve and learn along the way too, but I can't get away from the fact that she's no more experienced than the novices in terms of lifetime runs, but she's clear on ratings, and has her 7lb mares allowance. Whilst she's unbackable now, she's still the most likely winner. Sharjah also upheld the Champion Hurdle form yesterday as being the best on offer.
Saint Roi, Abacadabras (ignore yesterday with Gordon's all flat), and Saldier who looked fat as a pig, are all contenders though, and are big each way prices against Epatante. I wouldn't argue against anyone making a case for them.
I don't see how anything else comes into the picture unless you take the Silver Streak run literally, but even using the rose tinted spectacles view I don't believe he's improved that much at this stage of his career. We have a line on him from the last two Champion Hurdles already.
Goshen would need a switch to JP and the Martinstown juice to get back on track, Aspire Tower is as good as we saw yesterday. He was the one that looked hard fit. Song For Someone is winning Grade 2's all out against the also rans, Concertista won't come, and if Honeysuckle does she'll flop after being beaten for speed. If she's flat to the boards to beat Ronald Pump over two and half, it doesn't read well on the old course at Cheltenham.
I can't have Buveur D'air Maurice. A great Champion, but he's not been sighted for over two years now, lacks an entry, and has to overcome an horrendous injury. Add to that he'll be 10 by the time the Festival comes around, and I'd say he'd be JP's third string for the race if he did turn up. He'd want to be out by the end of January at the very latest to avoid bouncing as well. I also suspect he'd want further than two miles now as well, so the race would need to be a war and he'd have to be fit for his life to have any chance at all.