I took a a look at Nazreef last night and I was initially split down the middle of you two guys.
Looked at horse closely, I do think he's worth a punt, as I can find reasons for an improved performance compared to last year, when finishing 5th off the same mark.
He is a better horse on the a/w, but he's rated 16lb lower than his new mark and I can't say that's a bad h/cap mark today. He's also a horse that has no real continuity in races, so very hard to say he doesn't act here, etc.
If you try and find differences to last years run in the race;
Apart from his debut runs at 2 & 3 yo, he looks a better horse running off short intervals. Last years run come off a break.
Wore 1st time visor to win lto, which may find a little more improvement. His win came off a mark of 96. His win prior to this race last year was off 91.
Holland is 2/2 on the horse over a mile from only 3 rides. Jockey has his critics but I'd rate him over Block, especially on a prominent runner.
Trainer form is also much better than last year with a strike rate of 30% for the last 5 months.
The ground could become tacky, so the horse's bottle may come into play. Although his last two wins came on p/t, he looks a battler, with in running prices for both wins hitting 50.0 & 480.0. These kind of odds are quite common in small volume for the hold ups, but for a prominent runner, quite surprising.
I took a look at the draw, thinking it was a negative but it actually looks perfect, if simply looking previous runnings. 12 of the last 15 have won from double figure + draws, with the last two g/s races going to:
20,19,24,8,15,14
22.5,19,16,6,14.
I've backed it, with a small e/w saver on Oriental Scot.
Good luck Marble