Champion Stakes

(except those that are anti uk racing maybe)

:lol:

Who in God's name is anti uk racing what ever that means!? I think this does more harm to British racing by moving around the juvenile races and setting up a meeting in direct competition with two established international meetings meaning it is pretty much doomed to failure.

The French will continue to aim at the Arc and Breeders Cup meeting and Coolmore the same, thats just for starters.
 
Ive only been once, but better than Cheltenham?

Also, isnt it a bit dependent on UK racing fans for that atmosphere. Maybe they will chose the big day at Ascot in future

I've only been to Cheltenham twice a few years back and I can't really remember it but given my intense dislike of jumps racing, I am biased!

The best atmosphere on Arc day was Zarkava's year. The UK racing fans just provide a boozed up football match style atmosphere on Arc day.
 
setting up a meeting in direct competition with two established international meetings

Its already "in competition" with these meetings. There is room for all three. Not many racing fans are going to go to the BC ( and a lot dont like it anyway) anyway

There is room for five days of royal ascot and four days of Cheltenham. So why not one more big flat racing day between the single significant days at Longchamp and BC?
 
Originally Posted by EC1
old oxo hoss...Cape Blanco...end of analysis

back to a trip he stays :)
Horses like him contest this year in year out and don't win - Fame, Hurricane Run, Oratorio, Notnowcato all ran way below form as favourite in recent years as they had been on the go too long/had too many hard races/too recent a hard race.

no of runs this season

5 Twice Over
2 Vision D'Etat 4/1
5 Snow Fairy 6/1
2 Await The Dawn 7/1
6 Cape Blanco 71
6 Fuisse 10/1
8 Wigmore Hall 10/1
1 St Nicholas Abbey 12/1
3 Glass Harmonium 16/1
3 Gitano Hernando 16/1
6 Beethoven 20/1
6 Tazeez 20/1
25/1 Bar


Last few runnings of Champion Stakes - no of runs that year

6 Twice Over
5 New Approach
5 Literato
5 Pride
6 David Junior
4 Haafhd
2 Rakti
6 Storming Home
6 Nayef

I'm not sure where you getting your stats from Hamm..but they not really that accurate are they?

EC,
My point was far from lazy and even further from inaccurate, if you had bothered to actually read what I wrote, not what you think I wrote.

I mentioned a list of horses who had been favourite or near that position, or in other words fancied horses for the Champions Stakes. I then said there were 3 reasons why these horses failed to fire. You have taken that in a black and white fashion whereas for example, Twice Over running in a conditions race and listed race is not the same 2 runs as say Fame and Glory running in the Irish Champion Stakes and Arc.

So, if you take top level runs prior to the Champion Stakes for the disappointing favourites I referred to:
Fame and Glory - had contested 4 Group 1s, plus 2 other Group races (and had a late season finish the season before), and his Group 1 races included 2 in 4 weeks just 2 weeks before the CS.
Notnowcato - Had contested 4 Group 1s, 5 races in all prior to the CS.
Hurricane Run - Had contested 4 Group 1s, 5 races in all prior to the CS and was generally past his best come the CS (form had been going down all year).
Oratorio - Had contested 6 Group 1s prior to the CS.

Now, if you look at the last 7 winners of this race (not going back further as wasn't following racing intensely then and hence hadn't that in mind when making my point):

Twice Over - had contested 3 Group 1s prior to the CS.
New Approach - had contested 5 Group 1s but had 3/4 of a stone in hand on his rivals. Unbelieveably hardy horse - something we knew at the time from his 2 year old days and ability to win Derby after running in 2 Guineas. However, an exception to my general point.
Literato - had contested 1 Group 1 prior to the CS.
Pride - had contested 3 Group 1s prior to the CS.
David Junior - had contested 1 Group 1 prior to the CS.
Haafhd - had contested 2 Group 1s prior to the CS.
Rakti - had contested 1 Group 1 prior to the CS.
 
They are not in competition with the two....the Newmarket race is aimed at by UK trainers (and indeed the odd French) but is a second thought after the Arc for many and I see absolutely nothing in the plan to add more money to it (when it still lags behind France and US in those terms) that will change anything.

There is no need for another big meeting at the end of the year - they should have thought of something mid to late summer perhaps around York time. But they were determined to have something to end the year and compete with France.
 
Agree - the Champion Stakes will never ever compete with the Arc, and what is wrong with saying the French have the best European end of year meeting but English racing stronger at other times (Ascot, York).

The worst thing they have done that many havent commented on is the possible reduction of runners in the QE2 who may instead go to the Breeders Cup.
 
Give it ten years and the lure of Ascot and a proper british racing atmosphere and the arc will be a listed handicap played out to 2000 people and shunted to ATR2 between the dogs and jumping from Kelso.

Believe me

Clive, the atmosphere at Longchamp at Arc day trumps every British meeting comfortably - there is nothing RFC can do about this - there are already racing days of the quality of the revised Champions Day and the atmosphere not nearly as good as Longchamp.
 
As I've said before, I'm not sure why the BHA and France Galop couldn't have got their heads together and devised some sort of European rival to the Breeders Cup on Arc/Cambridgeshire weekend with the QE2, Sun Chariot, Middle Park and Cheveley Park in the UK on the Saturday and the usual Arc card on the Sunday (prob up the distance of the Jean Luc to 1 mile though).

Marketed properly, it could have been a huge occasion and they could've even joined forces with the Breeders Cup to provide substantial bonuses for horses that turn up Stateside a month later.
 
Now that is a good idea.

As I've said before, I'm not sure why the BHA and France Galop couldn't have got their heads together and devised some sort of European rival to the Breeders Cup on Arc/Cambridgeshire weekend with the QE2, Sun Chariot, Middle Park and Cheveley Park in the UK on the Saturday and the usual Arc card on the Sunday (prob up the distance of the Jean Luc to 1 mile though).

Marketed properly, it could have been a huge occasion and they could've even joined forces with the Breeders Cup to provide substantial bonuses for horses that turn up Stateside a month later.
 
It doesn't matter about the prize money, it's about the history of the race and tradition. The Arc will never be supplanted as the race of the Autumn.
 
As I've said before, I'm not sure why the BHA and France Galop couldn't have got their heads together and devised some sort of European rival to the Breeders Cup on Arc/Cambridgeshire weekend with the QE2, Sun Chariot, Middle Park and Cheveley Park in the UK on the Saturday and the usual Arc card on the Sunday (prob up the distance of the Jean Luc to 1 mile though).

Marketed properly, it could have been a huge occasion and they could've even joined forces with the Breeders Cup to provide substantial bonuses for horses that turn up Stateside a month later.

I, too, like this idea.

It was never going to happen quickly, but perhaps it is something that the respective authorities could work towards over the next few years, with RFC's recent actions arguably making it more rather than less likely. The Ryder Cup has shown that sports fans can stomach being temporarily European when it suits their purposes.;)

Would you mind if I quoted you some time, GS?
 
Champions Day as it was is an excellent meeting . I struggle to understand the need to move races around at the end of the year - why could the BHA not have asked the EPC for approval to upgrade the present Champions Day by making the Challenge and Rockfel G1 races. The Rockfel year after year produces top class fields and there is no G1 7f race in the UK and it would be two weeks after the Foret allowing specialist 7f horses to run in both .

Also why is no consideration given to upgrading the actual finale at Doncaster. A finale that did not attempt vainly to compete with the Breeders Cup but looked to fill in some gaps in the UK season .

For example , few sprinters go to the US - since the Haydock Park Sprint Cup was moved to Sept from early Nov in the 1970s there has been no top class sprint after the Diadem in the UK .

Also we have no 10f Group race for 2 year olds - they all have to run in the Criterium de Saint Cloud which is normally bottomless compared to Donny .

A G1 sprint over say the Portland distance and 10f 2 yo race would be more of a bang that just the November Handicap !
 
Last edited:
I, too, like this idea.

It was never going to happen quickly, but perhaps it is something that the respective authorities could work towards over the next few years, with RFC's recent actions arguably making it more rather than less likely. The Ryder Cup has shown that sports fans can stomach being temporarily European when it suits their purposes.;)

Would you mind if I quoted you some time, GS?

Not at all, as long as you insist the UK leg is not staged at Ascot wherever you quote me!
 
Champions Day as it was is an excellent meeting . I struggle to understand the need to move races around at the end of the year - why could the BHA not have asked the EPC for approval to upgrade the present Champions Day by making the Challenge and Rockfel G1 races. The Rockfel year after year produces top class fields and there is no G1 7f race in the UK and it would be two weeks after the Foret allowing specialist 7f horses to run in both .

Very good points.

Your first line is enough for me.
 
Champions day is not an excellent meeting... Not in my book anyway.. Lack of atmosphere, the Champion stakes is an average G1 at best and the main reason for going was the Dewhurst. If they move teh location and date it will then be colder, wetter, softer ground and they will be unlikely to fill Ascot so I can't see the atmosphere improving or the racing particularly. Having been to the Arc meeting this year, when not at its busiest, it still knocked socks off our current champions day. The guineas meeting is far more exciting.

I think the sentiment and over-riding aim of what they are trying to do should be supported but the timing sucks - It should be two or three weeks before the Arc - probably a week after the Leger. By mid October people are more concerned with the jumps. They should adopt the breeders cup approach of moving the meeting as well.

Regarding the race itself this year - Vision D'Etat is a very confident selection. He only lost twice over 10f - Once in the Dubai world cup which you have to strike a line through and then once in his first race of 2009. Ground, track, preparation all in his favour I think he will be very difficult to beat.
 
By mid October people are more concerned with the jumps.


Exactly. There is so much room in the calender for this initiative. Post Glorious Goodwood all you really have in two months is four days at York and then the Arc, the rest of it is just plain average.

I think one of the reasons NH is more popular these days is that even when it gets really mundane in the dog days of January and February Cheltenham is always getting closer so there is always something mouth watering to look forward to. Even Aintree seems to get better every year.

Back in the day in the early 00s and late 90s I was like 80% flat 20% Jumps but now it's more like 60/40 in the winter games favour.
 
Champions day is not an excellent meeting... Not in my book anyway.. Lack of atmosphere,

Agree entirely. Ive been twice and enjoyed it but its very downbeat considering the quality of racing on show. But disagree about Ascot. it wont be filled (would need 70000 for that) but the place is a genuine draw in itself for many racegoers (or pissheads as Hamm puts it...). Newmarket isnt really

The timing points are interesting
 
They should have a card full of Group 2's on the Saturday - £4 entry
A card full of Group 1s on the Sunday - £7 entry
Sunday should include Europe's most valuable race.
They should hold it on the outskirts of of the greatest city on earth.
They should sell ham and cheese baguettes.
 
Back
Top