I am sorry if I sounded so rude, but unfortunately, but my point is Black Caviar would not be beaten by Overdose.
Read the sectionals of Black Caviar, they are extraordinary. Especially from the TJ Smith Stakes when she came from 6 to 8 lengths on the bend, to home past another world class star in Hay List by 3 lengths. She should not have won that day.
Comparing a horse that wins a race in Rome, to a world champion, who has sectionals that are literally out of this world, is as I said ludicrous.
I am not defending her because she is Australian. To be perfectly honest she is not my favourite horse at all. Actually far from it, but I respect a champion. I am defending a horse that has 6 consecutive Group 1 races to her name, a horse that is UNDEFEATED in 13 starts, a horse that has numbers and sectionals which are phenomenal, a horse that is considered by many a judge world wide as the best to have raced at that distance all time, and the horse that is the highest rated sprinter of all time. That still remains to be seen, but if she wins in Hong Kong and beats another super star in Rocket Man, then yes she quite possibly will be.
Suny, it'd be no different in me saying that based on sectionals, and from his 1998 Cox Plate performance, Might And Power (who was one of the highest rated horses in the 90's) would easily beat Sea The Stars on common mutual territory. You and I both know how silly that is. There is no way Might And Power could or would beat Sea The Stars. He'd lead and see nothing but a nice rump and tail.
I rate Black Caviar very high, but so far she has not posted a 140 nce, I want to see her in England next season and lets hope she is able to prove.
At the moment she is superior to Hay List and looks top class but I have to see her here or in Hong Kong against an interanitonal field.
About Overdose
not so sexy profile and not so spectacular to see sprinters on softer ground but just imagine what could have been this horse trained in a better centres, treated by a better vets and better facililties.
About Sea The Stars
great horse but there can appear a horse in Germany or Italy able to beat him, Ribot was italian and won 2 Arcs.