He's no Sprinter mate in his novice years, I don't know what you're doing with those times .. its ridiculous. Simple question for you, has Douvan ever raced an 155 horse over hurdles or 165 horse over fences ? Simple as. You know he would've meet over hurdles horses rated above 170+ and over fences he'll meet horses above 180+? Thats a stone caliber above what he's been meeting. I have no problems anyone saying he can do IT, I have problems reading some posts that say he has already DONE THAT and he's already above those top class horses. I think they deserve more than to be compared with a horse with a 10 wins in a row against average novice opposition. Next simple question, has he ever won a G1 in open company?
Look up Simonsig, a high class quality novice horse in his day, Nicky saying he's the only horse to give a race to Sprinter in his pomp, similar novice performance with a Neptune and Arkle at the festival, and people on here calling me out for saying he would stand a chance when he made his belated comeback from injury 2 years later. Sure he failed but still was 3 lengths in behind Gods Own at P'town after a not so perfect season start. He will return again this season, what form he will return in I don't know but when telling me that Douvan is unique I'd tell you look back only a year ago Vautour, look back couple of years ago Simonsig, and so on. Horses that had a perfect start in novices and when going against older horses failed for some reason.
As for trusting Mullins words, listen to the latest Final Furlong Podcast, there's an argument in there for believing anything that AOB says and discarding anything that Mullins says cause its rubbish until you see it happen. AOB says his horse is not ready or he'll run there, thats the truth, Mullins says a horse is the next thing or he's in great form, it gets beat for lack of fitness or he doesn't run against real competition and dodges for a easier race.
Later Edit: And how does Mullins know what his horses are compared with each other? Anyone will tell you he doesn't race his horses against each other, at least novices against older horses etc. When he said he was the best horse he was referring of how docile he is and he does good pieces of work, he wasn't racing horses against each other in private mate. He rarely puts them in gallops against 1-2 good of his good ones so he can gather their class and regarding Douvan he said that he can stay up with his best ones, but for how long and how fast they were going no one knows.. Sure he's a high quality horse, you'd expect that otherwise you wouldn't hear him saying he works so well but there's a world apart from beating some of his stellar ones on a racetrack.