Westmanstown Golf Club – 3rd March 2010
Panel
Colm Murray (MC) CM
Davy Russell DR
Colm Murphy MPH
Donn McLean DM
Evan Williams EW
Barry Geraghty BG
Paddy Power PP
For the second Irish preview evening, we travelled to the beautiful Westmanstown Golf Club in Dublin, where there were around 500 people in attendance.
Supreme Novices
CM: Rock solid Irish favourite in Dunguib. Backbone of everyone’s doubles, and trebles…..
BG: If he jumps he wins, no doubt in my mind. But that is a big ‘if’. He might well struggle. Nicky Henderson is sweet on Bellvano.
DR: I don’t think his jumping was so bad last time because he was out the back asleep. With this in mind the quicker they go the better for him. I think he’ll be ok. Connections think he will win a big flat race. The biggest problem his young jockey will have will be holding on to him; he’ll win on the bridle.
MPH: Exceptional horse – he’s beaten very good horses easily. Probably two classes above everything else.
EW: Really interesting one is Oscar Whiskey. 10-1 is a fair price. How many hot favourites get beat in this race?
BG: Oscar Whiskey’s a very good, unbeaten horse, but hasn’t competed at the top level yet.
DM: No doubting Dunguib’s ability, but not as cut and dried as the betting suggests. This is a good race and it shouldn’t be odds on, and then 10-1 bar. Get Me Out Of Here was very impressive at Newbury last time. Currently rated 150, higher than last 5 winners of Supreme Novices’ after the race. Blackstairmountain is also very interesting. Dunguib might win but price isn’t right; should be odds against.
PP: It’ll cost us well over £1 million if Dunguib wins – minimum.
Neptune Investment Hurdle
CM: We think the Irish will win thanks to Rite of Passage.
EW: He’s jumping well but 3-1 is short enough. 14-1 on Quantitativeeasing is cracking value. They think the world of him.
DM: 3-1 is too short, but he is the most likely winner, very classy. Of the others, Quel Esprit and Fionnegas are appealing.
DR: I’m a big fan of Rite of Passage. Really classy sort. Peddler’s Cross is very interesting though.
MPH: Again, hard to see past the favourite. I know they really fancy them, all raving about him.
BG: Finians Rainbow, I think, is the business. He’s the horse I’m most looking forward to at Cheltenham. My biggest worry is Peddler’s Cross. On certain pieces of form Rite of Passage has no chance. I’d put a line right through him.
PP: Rite of Passage has a massive chance, and is a strong favourite.
Willie Mullins then joins on a conference call, and runs trough a few races and horses:
Quel Esprit is one of my better ones at the festival. Stays really well and will handle any ground. At 12-1 I’d have a lot E/W.
No decision yet on Mikael D’Haguenet. We were delighted with Cooldine on Sunday during schooling at Leopardstown.
Dunguib is in a different league, and is very hard to beat. Blackstairmountain has a solid E/W shout.
Sports Line: the Arkle looks a cracking race, but his work on Sunday was pleasing. His style of racing will suit the race. Shakervilz is not bad value at 33’s either. I’m happy with both my runners, but it’s a tough race.
Secant Star’s jumping may not be good enough, and that worries me.
Golden Silver is improving all the time, but I can’t see us beating Master Minded.
Uimhiraceathair is good value at 20’s for the RSA.
Jy Vole is a tough ride, and may be better going right handed so Scotsirish is better value at 33’s for the Ryanair.
Cousin Vinny hasn’t fired this year, and didn’t take to travelling last year.
Mourad may be better in the Coral Cup.
If Shot From The Hip turns up like he did last Sunday, then he’ll win the bumper.
Enterprise Park has got a great chance in the Albert Bartlett. I’m amazed that Tell Massini is favourite. Fionnegas may also run in this.
Triumph Hurdle
CM: Davy, what do you think?
DR: Nobody has any idea what will win! It’s a terrible race. They’re all flat rejects. Pittoni might not run. Ask Barry about Super Kenny……
BG: Last year was a good year. This year everything is beating each other. Advisor looked ok at Ascot the other day. Soldatino will improve a stone from his last win and has a good chance. I know nothing about Super Kenny!
EW: I quite like Carlito Brigante. Difficult race though; I’ve got Barazan and on good ground he’ll be in the first four.
MPH: I have no idea!
PP: Notus De La Tour is very interesting. Imperial Cup first and then bonus hunting in this. At 16-1 he has a massive chance
DM: No strong view, hard to weigh up, and the form is all over the place.
Champion Hurdle
CM: Barry, Punjabi again?
BG: He felt good at Kempton last time. I’m not too fussed about Zaynar’s Kelso defeat. I’m not sure what I’ll ride yet. Go Native is the one to beat though.
DM: Go Native should be shorter; he is the most likely winner.
EW: Go Native must be seriously respected. There is a little bit of value around though and Khyber Kim appeals.
MPH: I’m a Go Native fan but Solwhit has real guts and only ever does enough. Punjabi has been there and done it. It’s pretty wide open to be fair.
PP: Good race for us, open. Go Native maybe should be shorter but the betting is pretty much right.
DR: Stable form at Charles Byrne’s isn’t a worry for me. If Celestial Halo gets an easy lead he could be very dangerous. Solwhit is quality but the lack of course form is a worry. It’s a hell of a good race.
World Hurdle
CM: Sentry Duty Barry?
BG: Good E/W chance but then again Big Bucks is buying money at 8-13. Different class.
DR: 110% Big Bucks will win. War of Attrition E/W is good fun and he’s flying at home.
EW: Big Bucks has so much in hand. Not for me at the price though. Maybe Katchit E/W? Karabak could really hustle up the favourite.
MPH: Case of what will finish second behind Big Bucks. Maybe War of Attrition, maybe Sentry Duty.
DM: Of all the odds-on shots Big Bucks is the most solid. The race lends itself to multiple winners. Tidal Bay could run him close though.
PP: Big Bucks is featuring in all trebles we’re taking. He’s going to be very hard, if not impossible, to beat.
Arkle
Barry Geraghty has left the panel but has asked the MC to give his opinions on some of the races. His seat has been filled by Peter Daly (PD), who is involved in the ownership of lading Arkle fancy, Sports Line.
CM: We (the Irish) look to have a strong hand here…..
EW: I really like Somersby a lot. His jumping is perfect. There is plenty of class in the race but Somersby should go very close.
DM: Hell of a race. It has class oozing out of it. Captain Cee Bee should probably win and 7-2 is about right. I respect Somersby but am worried about his Sandown (Henry VIII) form.
DR: Captain Cee Bee shouldn’t be far away. Can’t have Sizing Europe, not sure over Somersby, or Tataniano. Keep it simple and stick with Captain Cee Bee.
MPH: I’m a Captain Cee Bee fan. He’s done nothing wrong really, apart from falling!
PD: Our horse (Sports Line) is in great form. He schooled really well on Sunday, all is going well, and we are very optimistic. It’s a big ask for him though with just two chase starts under his belt.
PP: Sports Line best backed in recent days. Captain Cee Bee is very solid though.
RSA Chase
CM: BG gives a big thumbs up to Punchestowns for this one.
PP: He drifted the other day but has tightened back up now.
MPH: Punchestowns looks the real deal. Weapons Amnesty will be better on good ground.
DR: Weapons Amnesty is a good horse, but a slow learner. He takes his time to figure out what’s happening. Wouldn’t have the class though I don’t think. If Long Run can win this as a 5 year old then fair play as it’s a huge ask. I’m happy enough with Weapons Amnesty though I suppose.
DM: Long Run doesn’t jump well enough. The Feltham is a terrible guide to this race too. Weapons Amnesty is solid and I’d have him on my side, along with Weird Al, my 2 against the field.
EW: Nicky Henderson will win it! Reverse forecast the pair. When he says they’re the best he’s trained then sit up and take notice. Bensalem E/W.
Queen Mother
CM: Big Zeb then Colm?
MPH: We’re very happy, wished we’d never gone to Tingle Creek but hindsight is a wonderful thing. I like to think we’ll run a big race but Master Minded is Master Minded. Jockey booking is up in the air at present.
DM: It’s going to be hard to get Master Minded beat, but not impossible. He’s a remarkable horse but how good is he? Big Zeb is over priced, Forpadydeplasterer isn’t out of it either.
EW: Kalahari King’s last win at Doncaster was sensational. I really think he could win it. A clear round for Big Zeb gives him a massive chance too.
PP: This race could easily cut up so maybe now is the best time to bet. Could get just 6 or 7 runners. Going to be very hard to beat Master Minded. I’d love to see Big Zeb win.
DR: Master Minded is beatable, vulnerable off the bridle. Kalahari King has a squeak but this looks wide open. Twist Magic has no chance.
PD: I have my doubts over Master Minded and I like Kalahari King instead.
Gold Cup
CM: Kauto Star, one of the greats.
EW: Absolute super star lets hope he goes there and wins. Cooldine to be second. Kauto Star by ten lengths.
DM: Superstar. Not a bet for me though at odds-on. Imperial Commander is 12-1 why? Big Price. Couldn’t have confidence in Denman. Calgary Bay without the ‘big two’.
DR: My head says Kauto Star but my heart says Denman. Denman hasn’t become a bad horse overnight, he knows how to beat Kauto Star. Get Sam Thomas back on board though. Tricky Trickster at a nice E/W price.
MPH: No doubt for me, Kauto Star. What finishes second? Denman probably. Cooldine is a serious E/W bet though.
PP: Cooldine and Imperial Commander dominate the ‘without big two’ market but I hope Kauto Star wins.
Champion Bumper
CM: Davy, what about Tavern Times?
DR: Lovely horse, slight worry though that he’s only had one run. He worked well the other day and is in good nick but I’d of liked another start under his belt. Shot From The Hip was impressive on Sunday but that looked a very tough race. Sorting Willie Mullins’ runners out isn’t easy and you’ve got to respect Dermot Weld – but Hidden Universe will not win!
DM: Elegant Concord is the best of Weld’s runners but it’s not a betting race for me. That said, Drumbaloo could be interesting at a half decent price.
EW: Ignore all the English runners! Shot From The Hip for me but wait till the day and follow the market!
MPH: Great betting race but this year looks very tough. Elegant Concord at a push.
PP: DM has it right, Drumbaloo is the one. Strong form and a very decent price (16/1). I’m not convinced by the Paul Nicholls trained Al Ferof and I’ve heard negative things coming from the yard.
PANEL’S NAPS
DM: Imperial Commander e/w – Gold Cup
DR: Peddlers Cross – Neptune Investment Hurdle
EW: Punchestowns / Long Run reverse forecast – RSA
PP: Drumbaloo – Champion Bumper
BG: Finians Rainbow – Neptune Investment Hurdle